Governance Alert: FedEx

by | Jun 16, 2022

FDX announces some important shareholder-friendly actions. With a new CEO and refreshed board, now’s the time for FDX to start delivering operational efficiency.

Dividend increases and important governance changes at FedEx. FedEx (FDX) announced some important shareholder-friendly updates, including increasing its dividend by more than 50%; adding two independent directors to its board as part of an agreement with long-time shareholder D. E. Shaw; and adding a Total Shareholder Return (TSR)-based performance metric to executive compensation program. D.E. Shaw holds ~1 million FDX shares (35th largest holder).

FDX shares have struggled in 2022 owing to margin pressures. FDX shares have declined 27% in the past year — versus a 13% decline for the S&P 500 over the same period. The company has been impacted by supply chain disruptions and tight labor market conditions. High transportation and labor costs have pressured FDX’s operating margins, which have been stuck below 7% since 2017.

FDX: Market Snapshot

Source: Boardroom Alpha

FDX shares have underperformed relative to the company’s larger rival, UPS. Reduced capital spending should help. Higher operating expenses, owing to wage pressures, coupled with increased costs related to network expansion have affected FedEx’s Ground segment, the company’s second largest business segment. More recently, the company has struggled to hire enough workers for its sorting hubs, hurting its on-time delivery performance. While FedEx’s operating margin hovers below 7%, the company’s larger rival, UPS– which hired former Home Depot CFO Carol Tome as CEO in June 2020– generated 2021 operating margin of 13.2% (up from 9.1% in 2020) while maintaining its on-time service.

FDX versus UPS Performance: August 2020 to Present

Source: Koyfin

TSR performance metric added to executive compensation program; another incentive to reduce CAPEX.  FedEX announced that its cash-based long-term incentive (LTI) program for F2023 – F2025 includes an additional performance metric tied to FedEx’s TSR relative to a broad market index. The LTI program also includes a CAPEX /Revenue performance metric. The CapEx/Revenue target metric in the new LTI program is lower than prior years to align with FedEx’s capital plans , and is expected to reduce CAPEX in out years. We applaud the alignment of management compensation with TSR and long-term value creation.

Compensation still a concern. 76% voted in favor of the company’s 2021 executive compensation plan. Notably, CEO, CFO and directors all paid above TSR, overall financial performance, and above peers.

FDX: 2021 Pay-for-Performance Assessment

Source: Boardroom Alpha

Two new independent directors on the heels of new CEO. FedEx added two independent directors, Amy Lane and Jim Vena, to its board, effective immediately, in coordination with activist investor, D. E. Shaw. A third independent director will be added to the board in consultation with D. E. Shaw group. Lane brings retail expertise while Vena spent over 40 years in the railroad industry at both Union Pacific (UNP) and Canadian National Railway Company (CNI) as Chief Operating Officer. These board changes come close on the heels of the June 1 appointment of Raj Subramaniam as CEO from founder and former-CEO Frederick W. Smith (who becomes executive chairman of the board). The two additions plus one retirement will leave FedEx with a 14-person board.

FDX: Board Snapshot

Source: Boardroom Alpha

FDX: A history of strong free cash flow

Source: Boardroom Alpha

A tale of reduced operating efficiency: FDX ROE and ROIC trending below peers

Source: Boardroom Alpha

53% dividend hike. FedEx raised its dividend by 53% to $1.15 /share ($4.60 annually, bringing dividend yield to 2.04%. The move underscores the company’s sound financial health as it utilizes free cash flow for enhancing shareholders’ returns. We think FedEx will revert to its historical policy of revisiting the dividend each year for a potential increase. Notably, from 2012 to 2018 the company increased its dividend annually before it peaked at $0.65/share for three years. In 2021, FDX paid a quarterly dividend of $0.75/share. In December 2021, FDX’s initiated a $5 billion share buyback (completed in May of this year).

FDX: Dividend and buyback overview

Source: Boardroom Alpha

FDX: Diversity & Inclusion Snapshot

Source: Boardroom Alpha

Competitive pressures are intensifying. Competition is changing for FedEx as more retailers ship directly from the store. Additionally, the US Postal Service is expanding its operations. The big one to watch is Amazon (AMZN), which is exploring extending its logistics service to also pick up packages. These changes would put Amazon in direct competition with FedEx and UPS.

Investor day will need to deliver evidence of strategic changes. FDX reports FQ4 earnings June 23rd. The company is hosting analyst and investor days June 28-29 (the first in over a decade). Expectations are running high into both as investors will looking at whether the recent changes represent a short-term boost to the stock or whether there is a longer-term growth story related to the recent CEO change. One of the most important changes will be for FedEx to unify the operations of its Express and Ground businesses, which are still run separately (and often overlap, creating excess costs). This won’t be an easy task, given that the Ground business is operated by independent contractors while the Express business owns aircraft and vehicles and has employees directly on payroll.

Still more work to do. Cutting back on CapEx spending while increasing the dividend rate are good short-term improvements for FedEx, but the real work lies ahead. Improving operating efficiency is key to this story, coupled with a strategy shift to address the changing competitive landscape. FDX shares trade at 8.4x EV-to-forward EBITDA and 6.7x forward cash flow– a discount to UPS, which trades at 9.7x and 10.5x, respectively. Given the recent move, we think there is some built-in expectation heading into both the quarter and the investor day. This is a ‘show me’ story until we see a path to margin improvement. We’re on the sidelines for now.

<a href="https://www.boardroomalpha.com/author/joanna/" target="_self">Joanna Makris</a>

Joanna Makris

Joanna has been analyzing and investing in emerging technologies for over two decades, having led the Technology, Media, and Telecom research at several global investment banks, including Mizuho Securities and Canaccord Genuity. Navigating stock market volatility since it all began in 2000. Banjo player, artist, and frittata-maker.

More from Boardroom Alpha

SPAC Market Review – January 2022

January saw the SPAC market fall quickly alongside the broader market as a revolt against “spec tech” and overall sentiment drove it lower.

Sonder’s Francis Davidson on Re-Designing Hospitality and Merger with GMII

For the latest Know Who Drives Return episode, we sat down with Francis Davidson, the founder and CEO of Sonder, a hospitality company that leases and manages travel properties. Sonder is valued at nearly $2B and is going public through Gores Metropolous II. Francis, at just 29 years old, has been able to rapidly scale the company that he founded 8 years ago as a student at McGill University in Quebec. Will Sonder succeed in grabbing a larger share of the lodging space? Have a listen and read our full report on the Sonder deal.

Amy Nauiokas on FinTech VC, SPACs, Diversity, and Anthemis Digital (ADAL)

We were fortunate to sit down with Amy Nauiokas, the Co-Founder, Co-Chair, and Co-CIO of fintech investing platform Anthemis ($1.2B in AUM), who has been a leading fintech investor for nearly 15 years. Though she has a career that us regular folks might find astounding given she also runs a film and television production company, Archer Gray, which promotes story telling from diverse individuals.

Know Who Drives Return

Objective, data-driven assessments for every public company director and officer.

Disclaimer

The opinions and information contained herein have been obtained or derived from sources believed to be reliable, but Boardroom Alpha cannot guarantee its accuracy and completeness, and that of the opinions based thereon. 

This report contains opinions and is provided for informational purposes only – it does not constitute investment, legal or tax advice. You should not rely solely upon the research herein for purposes of transacting securities or other investments, and you are encouraged to conduct your own research and due diligence, and to seek the advice of a qualified securities professional before you make any investment.  

None of the information contained in this report constitutes, or is intended to constitute a recommendation by Boardroom Alpha of any particular security or trading strategy or a determination by BA that any security or trading strategy is suitable for any specific person. To the extent any of the information contained herein may be deemed to be investment advice, such information is impersonal and not tailored to the investment needs of any specific person.  

No representation or warranty, expressed or implied, is made on behalf of Boardroom Alpha as to the accuracy or completeness of the information contained herein. Boardroom Alpha does not accept any liability for any direct, indirect or consequential loss or damage suffered by any person as a result of relying on all or any part of this research and any liability is expressly disclaimed. 

Executive Moves

Newsletter

Get it in your inbox weekly and don't miss a move